Skip to content
New York slip and fall accident attorney
Legal Insights | | 8 min

How Does The Slip & Fall Accident Settlement Process Work?

By Timothy Cellino

Slip and fall accidents contribute to over 800,000 hospitalizations each year in the United States, and often cause serious injuries to those involved.

There are various requirements that must be met for an injured party to make a claim against a property owner based on a slip and fall injury. As a result, injury victims should seek counsel from a trusted attorney to assist with a claim.

The fact of the matter is, every case is unique and will require an independent analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding the injured party’s fall. As a result, slip and fall cases do not follow a cookie-cutter timeline from start to finish. If you have been injured and are thinking of working with an attorney on your case, this is what you can generally expect in regard to the overall slip and fall settlement process.

Slip & Fall Settlement Process in 7 Steps:

Seek Medical Attention For Your Injuries

It’s extremely important to seek prompt medical care after a slip and fall accident, even if you feel your injuries may be minor in nature. In fact, injuries may seem unproblematic at the time of the accident but subsequently worsen over time, causing issues like loss of mobility, surgery, or semi-permanent pain. Failure to seek medical care at the time of the accident can delay your recovery period. It can also delay or diminish any settlements or recovery if you pursue a personal injury claim.

After you seek medical care from a trusted medical professional, it’s important that you follow the guidance of your treating physician until you have reached a full recovery. Depending on how severe your injuries are following the accident, recovering can take anywhere from weeks to several months or even years.

Speak To A Slip and Fall Injury Attorney For A Free Case Evaluation

After you’ve started to seek medical attention after your accident, it’s advisable to reach out to an experienced personal injury attorney in your area for a case consultation. During the consultation, be prepared to answer questions about the accident itself, your injuries and whether or not you are seeking ongoing medical care.

Since many personal injury attorneys in New York offer free case consultations, this is your opportunity to meet with as many attorneys as you’d like to determine who is the best fit for your case. During your consultation, you may want to ask questions pertaining to the legal process, the attorney’s experience with slip and fall cases, who within the firm will be handling your case, how often you can expect communication, and so on. Choosing the right attorney to handle your case can make the world of a difference when it comes to the compensation you receive for your injuries.

File An Insurance Claim

After you’ve hired an attorney to handle your case, he or she will review all of your medical records and bills, wage loss verification, and any out of pocket expenses that you may have incurred due to your accident.

Once your attorney assesses your damages, they can begin to negotiate a settlement with the at-fault party’s insurance company. An attorney will evaluate all of the evidence available and will strategically present the facts and circumstances of your accident, injuries, treatment and financial losses to the insurance company in order to obtain a fair offer of resolution. Your attorney will inform you of any settlement offers made by the insurance company. If the insurance company will not offer fair compensation for your injuries, then your attorney may advise filing a lawsuit in an attempt to recover proper compensation for you.

Paperwork Is Filed With The Court

If your attorney is not able to reach a fair settlement with the insurance company, they will begin the litigation process. In this process, your attorney will prepare a complaint setting forth the allegations against the defendant(s). Your attorney will file the complaint, among other paperwork, with the court. The defendant’s attorneys will then respond to the complaint, generally admitting or denying each allegation set forth in the complaint. A defendant’s answer will typically include affirmative defenses, or points that the defendant intends to prove in order to negate their liability.

Keep in mind that just because the litigation process has begun, your case may not make it all the way to trial. At any point during the suit, a settlement can be reached.

The Discovery Phase

As your case progresses (assuming a settlement has not been reached), your attorney will begin a process known as discovery. During the discovery phase, each party will exchange information, assess damages, and establish their defenses. During discovery, you most likely will be required to attend a deposition where you will provide sworn out-of-court testimony by answering defense counsel’s questions about the accident and injuries you have sustained as a result.

The pace at which the discovery phase moves depends on several factors including the jurisdiction that a case is filed in, the number of defendants named in your case, and the complexity of the case itself.

Mediation and Negotiations

After the discovery phase has come to a close, the parties may once again attempt to settle the case before trial, either through informal negotiations or by a formal mediation process. If your case goes to mediation, your attorney and defense counsel will need to agree on an impartial party to act as mediator.

During the mediation process, each party will have the opportunity to present their case to the mediator. After both parties have done so, the mediator will dismiss both parties to separate rooms. At this point, the mediator will engage in private discussions with each attorney, in an attempt to reach a fair resolution satisfactory to both sides. If mediation is unsuccessful and a settlement cannot be reached, the case will proceed.

Your Case Goes To Trial

If neither party can agree to a fair settlement at any point during the pre-trial stages, then your case will go to trial. A jury will be selected to hear both parties’ cases and decide who is at-fault (or more at-fault) in the accident. The jury will then decide the compensatory amount that can be awarded to you, the plaintiff.

If you or your attorney feel as though the jury made an incorrect decision, you will have the opportunity to appeal their decision.

Factors That Can Delay The Settlement Process

The Length of Your Medical Treatment

Generally speaking, settlement negotiations do not begin until you have completed your medical treatments or have reached maximum improvement. Depending on the severity of your injuries, this can mean that settlement negotiations with the insurance company can be on hold for months. It would be unwise to accept a settlement offer only to find that you require further treatment, for example surgery, and will incur further expenses related to your injuries.

Liability Disputes

Establishing liability and proving negligence is not only imperative in a slip and fall case, but can be extremely difficult to do depending on the complexity of your case. In order to succeed in a slip and fall case, you must prove by a preponderance of evidence that the landlord acted negligently. This might be more difficult to prove if you were on the property illegally, if there was signage warning you of the hazard, or if you could be partially at fault for your injuries.

The Insurance Company Is In No Rush To Settle

Insurance companies will often investigate the accident to find any piece of evidence that can potentially devalue your claim against their insured. While doing this, they may delay offering or paying out any settlements. This tactic is often used to exhaust injury victims in order to get them to settle for a lowball offer, which is why working with a trusted legal professional is suggested.

Eyewitness Accounts

While having an eyewitness account can be extremely valuable to your case, it may be difficult to contact a witness or gather information after the accident. Your attorney will need to interview any key witnesses, which will require locating and getting in touch with those individuals. Eyewitnesses can provide valuable proof to your case; it is a worthwhile investment to spend the time obtaining their accounts of an accident, where applicable.

How Cellino Law Can Help Slip and Fall Victims

Slip and fall accidents can be tricky to navigate on your own. However, having a personal injury attorney in your corner can save you time, stress, and help to increase your chances of receiving a favorable settlement amount from the insurance company.

The attorneys at Cellino Law are here to help. Our team has decades of experience both inside and out of the courtroom working with slip and fall injury victims, which means we can help you to recover the compensation you deserve for your injuries. To speak to one of our attorneys for a free case evaluation, contact us at 888-888-8888.

Content checked by the personal injury attorney Timothy Cellino

Timothy Cellino

As a family man and a trial attorney, I pride myself on winning cases and serving the community.
I understand the function of a jury, how juries arrive at conclusions, and the role that the jury plays in administering justice. I know how to win cases. You can find us in ManhattanBuffaloMelvilleRochesterBrooklynThe BronxQueens and other locations throughout New York.

Share this Article:

New York Personal Injury Lawyers

Client Testimonials

Over 1,000 Google Reviews →
Construction Accident

“thank you so much for putting your all into this and making sure my family and I wouldn’t have to worry anymore!”

— Anthony M.

Personal Injury

“They consistently went above and beyond to make sure my family and I were taken care of.”

— Ira M.

Manhattan, New York
Motorcycle Accident

“The excellent lawyers at Celino Law offices are assisting me with a recent motorcycle accident case.”

— Justin V.

Manhattan, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“I’m glad I chose Cellino Law, the best decision ever.”

— Joseph C.

Manhattan, New York
Personal Injury

“They were with me and my husband from the beginning to the end of our case.”

— Maria R.

Manhattan, New York
Personal Injury

“From the beginning they came out and met with my uncle and myself and assured us that everything would be taken care of from beginning to end.”

— Eshaunda R.

Manhattan, New York
Car Accident

“I’m very thankful that I took the step to reach out about my case with Cellino Law.”

— Selin S.

Manhattan, New York
Car Accident

“Instead of feeling like “just another case,” I felt valued and respected every step of the way.”

— Gabriella T.

Brooklyn, New York
Car Accident

““Best law firm around‼️”

— Karon O.

Rochester, New York
Mass Tort

“They made me feel comfortable throughout this experience. I was treated with respect and dignity, they kept me well-informed throughout the process, and the outcome was better than I could have expected. I highly recommend Cellino Law!”

— Sandy L.

Rochester, New York
Personal Injury

“they made me feel very comfortable, almost like a family member.”

— Carol W.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“AMAZING ATTORNEYS AND PARALEGALS!”

— Donna B.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“They have been respectful of our circumstances and responsive to our many questions. And they get results.”

— Nick P.

Rochester, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“I would highly recommend this law office to any individual that has gone through a traumatic experience. Very reliable, effective and efficient.”

— Tatyanna W.

Rochester, New York
Pedestrian Accident

“after being dropped by a Buffalo attorney who stated I would not even see $10,000 from my accident, the Cellino Law team were amazing and able to get me 9.5 times what the previous attorney said I would get.”

— Nichole L.

Rochester, New York
Slip and Fall Accident

“even when I felt doubtful going through a law suit the reassurance was there,I do recommend their services ,if you are looking for professional and concerned firm Cellino Law is it”

— Barbara B.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“I had the unfortunate experience of being involved in a car accident, but I was incredibly fortunate to have Cellino Law Firm represent me in my lawsuit.”

— Guinevere S.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“As someone who had never pursued legal action before, I appreciated how simple they made the process.”

— Brenda P.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“The start of every conversation I was asked how I was doing, how the recovery from my injury/surgery was going. They gave light in a dark time for me.”

— Jessica A.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“The staff made me feel valued and my case mattered.”

— Sharetta M.

Rochester, New York
Car Accident

“Took me from 6k to 120k. Helped me get a vital surgery with her representation that essentially saved my life.”

— Allan R.

Amherst, New York
Personal Injury

“I was impressed with how professional and patient my lawyer has been on this journey from the beginning to end.”

— Tabitha M.

Amherst, New York
Personal Injury

“I would 100% recommend Cellino Law for anyone needing a lawyer.”

— Megan S.

Amherst, New York
Truck Accident

“There aren’t enough words to express the professionalism, the respect, and genuine compassion that I was given from the very beginning of the first phone call.”

— Patti D.

Amherst, New York
Trip & Fall

“Cellino Law is one of the best law firms”

— Helen P.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“My case just resolved for a significant amount and I am extremely satisfied. If you are ever injured in a car accident don’t hesitate to call Cellino Law.”

— Monique B.

Amherst, New York
Trip and Fall

“They were professional and knowledgeable and helped my son receive the compensation he deserved.”

— K.R

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“I was in a car accident in February and didn’t know what to do next. That’s when I decided to contact Cellino Law and get some guidance. It was the best decision I could have made!”

— Katie B.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“Best Law Firm period!”

— Pedro A.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“Great team and very attentive. Highly recommend to anyone recently in a car accident.”

— Randi B.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They are very knowledgeable and take dedicated time to make sure you get what you deserve and will keep working to your best interest.”

— Katrina M.

Buffalo, New York
Personal Injury

“If you need a compassionate and skilled attorney, I highly recommend Cellino Law. They truly care about their clients.”

— J R.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“Their professionalism made a stressful situation much easier. Highly recommend!”

— Eric B.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They were incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and always made me feel supported and informed throughout the entire process.”

— Anne S.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“They treat you like more than just a case, and make you comfortable throughout the whole process.”

— Ann W.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“My attorney came to my home because at that point I was unable to walk…”

— Crisanne

Rear-End Accident

“…the attorney that they gave me was a godsend.”

— Merri

Slip and Fall Accident

“Recently I had a slip and fall at a restaurant and injured my knee. It led to me missing work and having to go to multiple doctors appts, MRIs and now PT. A friend of mine suggested I contact an attorney given the severity of the injury. I reached out to Cellino Law and spoke with Brigitte Cellino and her paralegal Katie C. They have been so helpful and informative throughout this whole process, and have been checking in on me frequently to see how I’m doing. Class acts at Cellino, the best around! Call them if you’re looking for a lawyer!”

— Paul K.

Buffalo, New York
Personal Injury

“I was hoping my attorney would help me figure out how I was going to help take care of my family…”

— Anthony

Car Accident

“I was in a car accident in February and didn’t know what to do next. That’s when I decided to contact Cellino Law and get some guidance. It was the best decision I could have made!”

— Katie B.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“Getting into a car accident is scary and stressful, figuring out what to do next is even more overwhelming. The staff at Cellino law firm are so kind, understanding and helpful. They treat you like more than just a case, and make you comfortable throughout the whole process. Brigitte Cellino and her assistant Katie C, are the best, and go above and beyond for their clients!”

— Ann W.

Buffalo, New York
Car Accident

“My attorney was able to find the woman that hit me and because of that we were able to have a case…”

— Paulette

Camper Trailer

“We had purchased a camper, and they didn’t put the lug nuts on the wheels…”

— Cristiane

Personal Injury

“I am incredibly grateful for the exceptional service provided by Cellino Law, specifically attorney Joseph DeGeneres and his outstanding assistant, Ian. From the very beginning, Joseph demonstrated a remarkable level of professionalism and expertise. He took the time to explain every detail of my case, answered all my questions, and provided honest, realistic expectations. Ian was always available to assist, ensuring that communication was seamless and that I was kept informed throughout the process. Their dedication and commitment to my case resulted in a favorable outcome, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. I highly recommend Cellino Law to anyone in need of legal representation.”

— Chris C.

Rochester, New York
Burn

“After Cellino Law helped me reach a settlement, my life has been a complete one hundred eighty.”

— Melissa

Rear-End Accident

Nick Davis, my lawyer from Cellino Law, listens! Shortly after I was severely rear ended in a car accident I realized I’d need a lawyer and sent emails to a few top companies. Nick Davis was the first to respond (others took days or didn’t respond) and he listened. He worked hard for me and always kept me informed. He and his paralegal Laurie Pecora were always available to answer my questions and explain the process. I am very happy with the outcome and highly recommend Cellino Law.”

— Sherry R.

Rochester, New York
Compound Fracture

“They were professional and knowledgeable and helped my son receive the compensation he deserved.”

— K.R.

Amherst, New York
Car Accident

“I can’t thank Cellino Law enough for everything they have done for me. When Denis Bastible took my case for a rear end car accident over 3 years ago I had no idea what this would turn into. I had to have 3 years of treatment on my back and eventually leading to a back surgery, which at 25 years old is a nightmare. Denis and his paralegal Marisa were nothing but a huge help to me the entire way through the lawsuit process. They were very reassuring that this would end well for me and extremely easy to contact throughout the entire process. If I could give them more than 5 stars I would.”

— Tyler M.

Amherst, New York
Truck Accident

“I said to them ‘if you were going to use a law firm who would you use?’ and time after time the name Cellino came up.”

— Andre

Truck Accident

author image
Truck Accident

Truck Accident

Yes, You Have A Case.

Fill out the form below and we will respond to you shortly.